Blog

Stay up to date with Connole Carlisle’s blog series about everything accounting & finance related

Missed the Director ID Deadline?

Have you missed the deadline to apply for a director identification number (director ID)? If so, you can still apply! The ATO says it will take a reasonable approach with directors who are trying to do the right thing. Importantly, directors who need additional time to apply (beyond 14 December 2022), can request an extension of time by completing an Application for an extension of time to apply for a director ID.

To recap, a director ID is a unique 15-digit identifier that a company director applies for once and keep forever. By allowing regulators to trace directors’ relationships with companies over time, director IDs will help prevent illegal activity and level the playing field for businesses.

Director IDs are administered by the Australian Business Registry Services (ABRS), which is managed by the ATO.

WHO?

You need a director ID if you are an eligible officer of:

  • a company, a registered Australian body or a registered foreign company under the Corporations Act 2001 (Corporations Act)
  • an Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander corporation registered under the Corporations (Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander) Act 2006 (CATSI Act).

An ‘eligible officer’ is a person who is appointed as:

  • a director
  • an alternative director who is acting in that capacity.

You also need a director ID if you are a director of a:

  • corporate trustee, for example, of an SMSF
  • charity or not-for-profit organisation that is a company or Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander corporation
  • registered Australian body, for example, an incorporated association that is registered with the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) and trades outside the state or territory in which it is incorporated, or
  • foreign company registered with ASIC and carrying on a business in Australia (regardless of where you live).

WHO DOESN’T?

A director ID is not required if you are a director of an incorporated association (with no ABRN) registered with the Australian Charities and Not-for-profits Commission (ACNC), company secretary but not a director, acting as an external administrator of a company, run your business as a sole trader or partnership.

It has also been recently clarified by the ABRS that directors who resigned their directorship before 31 October 2021 are not required to obtain a director ID. Deceased directors, as they are unable to personally apply, are also exempt.

In summary, if you run a company that is a small business, are a corporate trustee of an SMSF, operate a not-for-profit or even a large sporting club, it’s quite likely that you’re a director, and therefore you’ll need to apply for your director ID.

HOW?

The easiest way to apply for a director ID is online at the ABRS website – www.abrs.gov.au/directorID. To access the online application, use the myGovID app with at least a standard identity strength to log in to ABRS Online. You must apply personally – we as your advisor cannot apply on your behalf, however we can advise you around eligibility, and answer any other questions you may have.

While we cannot apply for adirector ID on your behalf, we can advise you around eligibility, and answer any other questions you may have.

2023-02-01T11:37:15+10:00February 1st, 2023|

FBT exemption for electric vehicles

Electric vehicles are set to become more affordable for both households and businesses after the government sealed a deal with crossbench Senators on legislation to exempt low and zero emission cars from fringe benefits tax (FBT).

The new law introduces an electric car discount in the form of an FBT exemption. This allows for car fringe benefits comprising the use or availability for use of an eligible car that is a zero or low emissions vehicle to be exempt from FBT.

Specifically, a car benefit will be an exempt benefit for a year of tax if:

  • the car is a zero or low emissions vehicle (note the scheme has been extended to include plug-in electric and internal combustion hybrids until 1 April 2025)
  • the value of the car at the first retail sale was below the luxury car tax threshold for fuel efficient vehicles (currently $84,916), and
  • the car is first held and used on or after 1 July 2022.

The FBT exemption would mean a customer with a gross income of $95,000 using a 36-month novated lease through their employer to purchase a 2022 Tesla model Y would see their take-home pay reduced by $1,364 a month, compared to $1,863 under the current rules, according to Inside Edge. Over the course of the lease, the total saving to the buyer would be $29,451 compared to a standard car loan.

Employers are the other big winners from the changes, which will remove the FBT liability on company-owned electric vehicles provided as part of a salary package for personal use by employees.

Under the earlier example, a Tesla valued at $64,000 currently results in a company FBT charge of around $12,500, according to Treasury calculations. This would be reduced to nil where the conditions above are met.

Car fringe benefits that are exempt from FBT will continue to be included in the employee’s individual fringe benefits amount for the purposes of determining the employee’s reportable fringe benefits amount for each FBT year in which the exempt benefit is provided.

Your reportable fringe benefits amount is used for:

  • calculating your liability for the Medicare levy surcharge
  • calculating your adjusted taxable income in determining whether a child is a dependant for Medicare levy purposes
  • determining your entitlement to the private health insurance rebate
  • determining whether you are liable for Division 293 tax for superannuation contributions
  • determining your eligibility for the government co-contribution for personal superannuation co-contributions you made
  • determining your eligibility for the low-income super tax offset for concessional (before tax) super contributions you or your employer pays into your super fund
  • determining whether you can offset your business loss against other income (non-commercial losses)
  • working out if you are entitled to reduce your employee share scheme discount
  • working out the amount you must repay against your
    • Higher Education Loan Program (HELP)
    • Vocational Education and Training Student Loan (VETSL)
    • Student Financial Supplement Scheme (SFSS)
    • Student Start-up Loan (SSL)
    • ABSTUDY Student Start-up Loan (ABSTUDY SSL)
    • Trade Support Loan (TSL) debt
  • determining your entitlement to a tax offset for
    • contributions you made to your spouse’s superannuation
    • invalid and invalid carer
    • zone or overseas forces
    • Medicare levy surcharge (lump sum payment in arrears)
    • seniors and pensioner
  • determining your eligibility for family assistance payments, including
    • Family Tax Benefit Part A and Part B
    • Child Care Subsidy
    • Parental Leave Pay
    • Dad and Partner Pay
  • working out your child support obligations.

Contact us if you would like to know more about this new law.

2022-12-01T14:32:16+10:00December 1st, 2022|

New work from home deduction rules

The ATO has issued new draft guidelines around a new method (the revised fixed rate method) of calculating work-from-home running expenses from 1 July 2022 (as an alternative to calculating the actual work-related portion of all running expenses).

The new revised fixed rate method will replace both:

  • the 52 cents fixed-rate method set out in paragraph 5 of Practice Statement PS LA 2001/6 (for electricity and gas expenses, home office cleaning expenses and the decline in value of furniture and furnishings), and
  • the short-cut (COVID-19) 80 cents method (for all additional running expenses).

You are eligible to use the revised fixed-rate method from 1 July 2022 if you:

  • work from home to fulfill your employment duties or to run your business (a separate home office or dedicated work area is not required)
  • incur additional running expenses that are deductible, and
  • keep and retain records of the time spent working from home and of the additional running expenses incurred.

New rate

The new rate of 67 cents (replacing the fixed rate of 52 cents in PS LA 2001/6) was “based on the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) household expenditure survey with consideration of annual Consumer Price Index (CPI) weightings”. However, given that the recent Federal Budget forecast a 50% increase in electricity bills alone over the next two years, the adequacy of the new 67 cent rate is open to question.

Furthermore, in arriving at the new rate, there was no explanation or reconciliation to the 80 cents per hour rate in place under the COVID-19 shortcut method. The new 67 cent rate represents a 16.25% reduction on that COVID rate.

Further undermining the adequacy of the new 67 cent rate is that it is inclusive of certain expenses that were not included under the former 52 cent rate. As noted in footnote 3 of PCG 2022/D4, the fixed-rate method in PS LA 2001/6: allowed 52c per hour for each hour a taxpayer worked from their home office to calculate their electricity and gas expenses, home office cleaning expenses and the decline in value of furniture and furnishings. In addition, a separate deduction for the taxpayer’s work-related internet expenses, mobile and home telephone expenses, stationery and computer consumables and the decline in value of a computer, laptop or similar device could be claimed.

However, PCG 2022/D4 at paragraph 23 proposes that the revised 67 cent fixed rate under the new rules is inclusive of:

  • internet expenses
  • mobile and/or home telephone expenses, and
  • stationery and computer consumables.

The inclusion of these expenses within the revised fixed rate, when coupled with the current high inflation environment, means that there is a high likelihood that taxpayers may be worse off when moving from 52 cents to 67 cents.

Record keeping

From 1 January 2023, this will become more onerous under the new revised fixed rate method.

Under that method, you will need the keep a record of the actual hours worked from home (e.g. timesheets, rosters or a diary kept contemporaneously). This is more onerous than the 52 cent method where you only needed to keep a record to show how many hours you worked from home. You could do this over the course of the year, or if your work from home hours are regular and constant, by keeping a record for a representative four-week period. The ATO under the new revised fixed rate method also requires evidence in relation to each of the running expenses listed above. For energy, mobile and/or home telephone and internet expenses, one bill per item needs to be retained. If the bill is not in your name, additional evidence is needed to prove that you incurred the expenditure. For stationery and computer consumables, one receipt needs to be kept for an item purchased.

Summary

All told, under the new method, the amount that can be claimed will potentially be lower, while the compliance obligations are higher – the taxpayer not only needs to keep a record of times spent working from home, but also there is a need to keep an invoice/receipt for each of the additional costs, such as an electricity bill. This is a new requirement which never formerly existed under either of the replaced fixed rate methods.

While the new draft guidance offers a transitional arrangement until December 2022, individuals currently availing themselves of the 52 cent fixed rate method will need to consider whether they can meet the additional administrative burden from 1 January 2023, or whether the “actual expenses” method is a more achievable alternative.

If you are uncertain which method is best for you, contact us directly to discuss your circumstances.

2022-12-01T14:28:17+10:00December 1st, 2022|

On-boarding employees for the holiday rush

Hiring additional employees to help with surging end-of-year demand? A New employment form, accessed through ATO online services, will help reduce your compliance time.

It’s an easy way for your employees to provide you and the ATO with the information that the ATO need. If your new employee has a myGov account linked to the ATO, once signed in they can:

  • access ATO online services
  • go to the ‘Employment’ menu
  • select ‘New employment’ and complete the new form.

Your employees will need your ABN to complete the form. When they submit the form, their tax file number (TFN) declaration details are sent straight to the ATO, so you as their employer do not need to do this. The form will then enable them to print and give you the summary of their tax details. You’ll need the summary so you can input the data into your system.

The New employment form can also be used to collect a range of information. For example, employees can use it to authorise variations to the amount you withhold from their pay for tax or the Medicare levy, or to advise you of their choice of super fund. They can also use it to update their tax circumstances with you, for example, if:

  • their residency status has changed
  • they no longer have a government study and training loan
  • they are claiming the tax-free threshold from a different employer.

This is an alternative to your employee completing a Tax file number declaration and Superannuation standard choice form to obtain their details.

When your employee completes the online commencement forms, this needs to be done within 28 days of them starting.

Other issues

You’ll also need to confirm your new worker is legally allowed to work in Australia. Australian citizens, permanent residents and New Zealand citizens are legally allowed to work here. If you believe the worker is a foreign national (other than a New Zealander), you must confirm they have a visa with permission to work. More information about employing migrant workers is available on the Department of Home Affairs website.

If you’re hiring someone on a working holiday visa (subclass 417 or 462), you must also register as an employer of working holiday makers. You need to do this before paying them.

If your business has a contract with a labour-hire firm, then they’re responsible for pay as you go (PAYG) withholding, super guarantee and fringe benefits tax obligations. Regardless of how the activity is described, if a labour-hire firm supplies workers to your business, they must withhold from payments to individual workers.

To be clear, it is the labour-hire firm that needs to withhold tax from individual workers under a labour-hire arrangement whether they are an employee or independent contractor.

As your tax practitioner we can help you with the tax and super issues surrounding putting on a new worker, including determining if they are an employee or contractor.

2022-12-01T14:24:22+10:00December 1st, 2022|

Single member SMSFs

From 1 July 2021, the law was changed to allow for six-member SMSFs (up from five members).

At the time of writing, the uptake has been slow so far with just 228 funds with six members. At the other end of the spectrum, it is permissible to have single member funds. The main advantage of doing so is that you have total control over your retirement savings, and the investment decisions in respect of those savings. However, there are some issues to be mindful of.

Number of trustees

An SMSF trustee is a person responsible for ensuring an SMSF is maintained for the purpose of providing retirement benefits, and complies with the investment and regulatory rules. The trustee can be a company or an individual. You can set up your SMSF with only one member; however the superannuation legislation requires you to have two individual trustees or a corporate trustee for the fund.

If you have a corporate trustee for a single-member SMSF:

  • The corporate trustee company can have one or two directors, but no more.
  • The fund member must be the sole director or one of the two directors.
  • If there are two directors and the fund member is an employee of the other director, the fund member and the other director must be relatives.

If you choose to have a corporate trustee:

  • The corporate trustee company can have one or two directors, but no more.
  • The fund member must be the sole director or one of the two directors.
  • If there are two directors and the fund member is an employee of the other director, the fund member and the other director must be relatives.

Loss of capacity

If the sole member loses legal capacity, then the person who holds an enduring power of attorney for the member may act as trustee of the fund in their place. This is an important matter to attend to before setting up your SMSF.

If the sole member was also the sole director of a trustee company, then the shareholder of the company will need to appoint a replacement director.

If the member was the only shareholder, then the probate of the member’s will needs to be granted before a new shareholder is appointed.

Death

In the event that the sole member passes away, then the other trustee will be left with total control of the fund. If the sole member was also the sole director of a trustee company then the same consequences from the loss of legal capacity will appy (see earlier).

Retaining residency

The SMSF must remain an Australian

superannuation fund in order to retain its complying status. Whether the super fund does so depends on meeting the following tests:

  1. Be established in Australia.
  2. Have its central management and control ordinarily in Australia.
  3. The fund must have either at least 50% of the fund’s assets linked to active members who are residents in Australia or not have any active members.

Thus, having a single member SMSF may limit your ability to travel overseas for extended periods.

All told, there is no ideal number of members to have in your SMSF, and it will depend on your circumstances.

2022-12-01T14:21:46+10:00December 1st, 2022|

SMSF compliance: what’s on the ATO’s radar?

In a recent speech, ATO assistant Commissioner Justin Micale outlined the ATO’s latest compliance issues for those who operate an SMSF.

ID fraud and investment scams

While ID fraud and investment scams are still quite rare in the SMSF sector, they are becoming more prevalent.

In the 2022 financial year, the ATO identified increasing numbers of individuals who were victims of identity fraud where SMSFs were registered without their knowledge or consent. Luckily for most victims the ATO detected the fraud early so it could protect their super, but not for all.

These scammers are becoming increasingly sophisticated, impersonating well-known Australian companies and using personal details to gain trust.

They use various methods to contact people such as email or cold calling, pretending to be financial advisers and encouraging them to transfer their superannuation into a new SMSF or investment product. The investor is often promised high returns.

Once they have their personal information, they seek to use it to establish an SMSF, rollover money into the fund and steal retirement savings.

This reinforces the need for individuals to treat contact from any third parties in relation to their investment and superannuation choices with an abundance of caution.

Illegal early access

Early access is the most common risk in the sector.

It occurs when individuals access their retirement savings before meeting a condition of release. Not only is this illegal, but money taken out of superannuation early has a detrimental impact on an individual’s retirement nest egg.

There are only limited circumstances where a member can legally withdraw their super early, such as where a member reaches their preservation age and retires, is 65 years old (even if not retired) or has died.

Non-lodgment of SMSF annual returns

The lodgment of an SMSF annual return is a fundamental obligation for all trustees/members including those in retirement phase.

There are around 24,000 funds who haven’t lodged their first return and a further 80,000 lapsed lodgers with one or more outstanding returns.

Lodgment is vital to ensure your SMSF retains its complying status on SuperFund LookUp as funds which have overdue returns by more than two weeks may have their regulation details removed. This restricts the SMSF from receiving rollovers and employer contributions.

Regulatory contraventions

In the 2022 financial year, the ATO received contravention reports for 13,558 funds with 39,997 contraventions being reported. This is an increase of nearly 3.5% in the number of SMSFs with contravention reports lodged and an increase of nearly 6.3% in the number of contraventions reported compared to the 2021 financial year.

The most common contravention relates to members having accessed their retirement savings early, which is often reported as a loan to a member or a payment standards breach.

The main drivers of regulatory contraventions are financial stress, poor record keeping and a lack of understanding of the rules.

Audits

Adequacy and independence were two key issues identified.

Key to a robust audit is the SMSF documentation. Trustees and their advisors must provide their nominated auditor with all the relevant documentation for the SMSF’s accounts and financial transactions for the year.

Record keeping is key. Documentation of an SMSF audit itself is also necessary to determine that the audit has been properly conducted. This is the case even if there were no contraventions.

Trustees also need to appoint auditors who are genuinely independent.

Director IDs

All existing directors, including directors of a corporate trustee of an SMSF, are now required by law to have a director ID by 30 November 2022. It’s not too late to comply, as the ATO is taking a softly-softly approach to compliance in this area.

If you have any questions around SMSF compliance, we’re here to help.

2022-12-01T14:18:56+10:00December 1st, 2022|

Xmas gifts from employers

Christmas is traditionally a time of giving, including employers showing gratitude to their workers for a job well done throughout the year. However, depending on the nature and value of the gift, and also who it is gifted to, such magnanimity can attract unwanted tax consequences. So how as an employer do you gift most tax-effectively this festive season?

Gifts to employees and their associates (e.g. spouses)

The first step is determining whether the gift constitutes entertainment. Gifts that constitute entertainment include tickets to movies, plays, sporting events, theatre, restaurant meals, holiday airline tickets, and admission tickets to an amusement park. On the other hand, the following gifts are not entertainment: Christmas hampers, bottles of alcohol, gift vouchers, perfume, flowers, and pen sets.

Where an entertainment gift costs less than $300 (GST-inclusive) and is provided infrequently throughout the year, there will generally be no Fringe Benefits Tax (FBT), no deduction will be allowed, and no GST credits can be claimed. Where the cost is $300 or more, FBT will apply, and a deduction and GST credits can be claimed.

Where a non-entertainment gift is in play, and it costs under $300, no FBT will apply, but a deduction and GST credits can be claimed. Where the cost is $300 or more, FBT will apply, and a deduction and GST credits can be claimed.

All told therefore, the best result for an employer (at least from a tax standpoint) is to provide a nonentertainment gift under $300.

Gifts provided to third parties (e.g. clients, suppliers, contractors etc.)

Where gifts are provided to these recipients, the $300 threshold has no relevance.

Gifts that constitute entertainment (irrespective of cost) do not attract FBT, cannot be deducted, and no GST can be claimed.

By contrast, non-entertainment gifts do not attract FBT, however a deduction and GST credits can be claimed – again, irrespective of cost.

Cash bonuses

Alternatively, instead of gifts, employers may wish to provide cash bonuses to their staff. From a tax perspective, the attraction of doing so is that it shifts the tax burden away from the employer and onto the employee. That is, the cash counts as assessable income for the employee while the employer can claim a deduction. No FBT is payable by the employer on a cash bonus.

Leave bonus

Another benefit that may be considered by employers is a leave bonus. For example, allowing workers to finish up for the year a couple of working days before Christmas and not have that count against their annual leave balance, noting that this may be a quiet time of the year for business anyway. There are no adverse tax consequences for either party. The added benefit for the employer is that, unlike a cash bonus, there is no immediate cashflow impact.

If you need assistance with the tax treatment of your Christmas giving, including Christmas parties, don’t hesitate to reach out to us.

2022-12-01T14:15:38+10:00December 1st, 2022|

Protecting your au domain name

The ATO Commissioner has just issued a warning to businesses on the importance of securing your au domain name!

To recap, .au direct domain names were launched earlier this year by the organisation that manages Australian domain names, the Australian Domain Administration (auDA). This will allow businesses to elect to drop the .com from their web addresses.

.au has been introduced, after ongoing significant public consultation, to complement the existing ‘namespaces’ (e.g. .com.au, .net.au and .org.au) for those domain names with direct verified connection to Australia. Its purpose is to deliver a wider choice of available names in the Australian domain, allow users to register shorter online names and provide names that are easier to type and display on mobile devices.

This change will align Australia with many other countries including the UK, Canada, USA and New Zealand.

To keep your business safe and undisrupted a consistent .au online presence will help to reduce the risk of unwanted parties piggybacking on your online brand / domain names. It is recommended that your equivalent .au direct domain is purchased.

Anyone can register your business’s .au equivalent domain name unless you have secured it.

Since March this year, businesses with an existing domain name (i.e. those whose websites end in .com. au or .net.au) have been given priority to reserve their matching .au domain name. For example, a business with an ‘ato.com.au’ domain name can also register as ‘ato.au’.

Remember to consider the benefits of registering an .au domain for your business and your individual circumstances. One of the benefits of registering is that you safeguard your brand’s identity on the internet.

If you don’t reserve your business’s .au domain name, impersonators, web name campers or cyber criminals may potentially take it. The Australian Cyber Security Centre has issued an alertExternal Link on the risk of cyber criminals using your brand’s domain to impersonate your business and conduct fraudulent cyber activities.

You can register your domain name’s .au equivalent at www.auda.org.au/au-domainnames/ au-domain-names/au-direct or through www.auda.org.au/accreditedregistrars to protect the digital identity of your brand.

In most cases, there will only be one registrant eligible to apply for a reserved .au direct name as they will be the only holder of its match in another .au namespace (e.g. .com.au, .net.au and .org.au). This is referred to as an uncontested name.

In these cases, the applicant will be allocated the domain name shortly after applying for Priority Status. The registrant will be able to choose a licence term of between one and five years.

For contested names (names where different registrants have the same name in different namespaces), the earlier the creation date of your current domain name the higher the priority and the more likely you are to be allocated your requested name.

2022-11-01T10:45:07+10:00November 1st, 2022|

Do I have to pay myself super as a business owner?

Do you have your own business or are you thinking of starting one? If so, you may need to pay yourself superannuation depending on your business structure.

Types of business structures available

If you were working for a company, your employer would be required to pay you superannuation guarantee (SG) contributions of 10.5% of your earnings to your chosen superannuation fund.

However when you’re running your own business and paying yourself, it’s not always clear if superannuation is compulsory as it depends on the trading structure of your business.

There are four commonly used business structures in Australia. These include:

  • 1. Sole trader
  • 2. Partnership
  • 3. Company, and
  • 4. Trust.

It is important to understand the responsibilities of each structure because the structure you choose will have different superannuation obligations.

Summary of superannuation requirements

The table below summarises whether SG contributions will be required to be paid under each business structure.

Regardless of your business structure, you will need to pay SG contributions for any eligible workers you employ to help run your business.

Despite not having to pay SG contributions under certain business structures, you may still consider making contributions into superannuation to save for your retirement due to the low tax environment within superannuation. A further benefit is that you may also claim a tax deduction for any concessional contributions, such as personal deductible contributions, that you make to your superannuation fund up to a limit of $27,500 a year. Other types of concessional contributions that also count towards the $27,500 limit include SG contributions and salary sacrifice contributions.

Business structure SG contributions required for business owner?
Sole trader
Partnership
If you’re a sole trader or a partner in a partnership, you don’t have to make SG contributions to a superannuation fund for yourself as you are not seen as an “employee” of your business (or partnership).
Company If you operate your business under a company structure, you are required to pay yourself SG contributions, even if you’re the company’s only employee/ director.
Trust If you operate your business under a trust structure, the trust may need to pay SG contributions to you as a trustee if you are employed by the trust.

Need help?

Choosing the right business structure and knowing what your obligations are can be complex. Remember, you’re not locked into any business structure and you can change the structure as your business changes or grows. Please don’t hesitate to contact us if you’re unsure which business structure to choose or whether you should be paying yourself superannuation, even though you may see yourself as being self-employed.

2022-11-01T10:48:54+10:00November 1st, 2022|

Rental expenses in excess of income not deductible

With many parts of Australia in the grip of a rental crisis, a significant number of tenants may be residing in the properties of friends and relatives.

A recent case that came before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT), Rizkallah and FCT [2022] AATA 3081, is a timely reminder that rental expenses in excess of income may not be deductible in these circumstances. Instead, the deductions may be limited to your income from the property.

The taxpayer acquired a unit in Sydney for $300,000 in September 2010, financed by way of a mortgage. After using it as her principal residence for about six months she found it difficult to keep up with the mortgage payments and commenced letting the property to a tenant after moving back in with her parents, who lived across the road.

In May 2015 the taxpayer’s future husband arrived in Australia on a partner visa sponsored by her. He joined the taxpayer, living with her in her parents’ house. The couple married in August 2015 and moved into the taxpayer’s property for about one month, after which time they split up due to the husband’s gambling addiction.

Keen to keep her estranged husband nearby in the hope of a reconciliation, the taxpayer then came to an informal tenancy agreement with her husband for $1,016 per month, to be paid in cash. She claimed this reflected the going rate for comparable housing in the area, although it subsequently emerged at the hearing that the market rate was at least double the rate she struck with her husband.

In her 2016 and 2017 income tax returns, the taxpayer disclosed the rent received as assessable income, but claimed net losses of $24,200 and $23,500 respectively, due to significant claims for interest, capital allowance deductions (that is, depreciation on the building) and other expenses, including repairs and maintenance.

In relation to the capital allowances claim (totaling $22,100 over the two income years), on being notified of an audit the taxpayer produced invoices totaling almost $200,000 from a company associated with her family which turned out to have been deregistered at the relevant time. She subsequently withdrew her capital allowances claim, saying the work was never undertaken nor the expenditure incurred, without offering any explanation as to her basis for making the claim in the first place.

The ATO disallowed the net losses claimed in both years and imposed a 50% shortfall penalty on the basis of recklessness. The taxpayer sought a review in relation to both the disallowance of her claims and the penalties imposed.

The main question addressed by the AAT was whether the expenditure claimed (other than the withdrawn capital allowance claim) was deductible – was it necessarily incurred in gaining or producing assessable income, or was it incurred for some other purpose?

The AAT agreed with the Commissioner that the arrangement was non-commercial because: (a) the property was rented to the taxpayer’s former partner in an attempt to facilitate the reconciliation of the relationship (b) the rent was well below market rates (c) no tenancy agreement was lodged with authorities. All told, the rent payable was below market rates and based on non-commercial considerations.

The tribunal therefore held that deductions were only allowable up to the extent of the rental income disclosed.

2022-11-01T10:40:06+10:00November 1st, 2022|
Go to Top